7 Must-Try Batavia Restaurants | Top Batavia Restaurants

Rate this post

Where in the world is Batavia, New York? It lies midway between Rochester and Buffalo, not far from Niagara Falls. Batavia is recognized as Western New York’s birthplace. The Holland Land Office partitioned and sold property to early American immigrants.

Visiting more places in the area? See our other guides:

  • 5 Must-Try Vegan Pizza Brooklyn
  • 10 Must-Try Jersey City Restaurants 
  • 10 Must-Try Restaurants In Rochester NY
  • 5 Best Restaurants in LeRoy, New York
  • 7 Best East Tremont Restaurants
  • 7 Must-Try Saratoga Springs Restaurants
  • 7 Must-Try Churchville NY Restaurants
  • Five Best NYC Ice Cream Shops
  • 5 Best Restaurants In SoHo NYC
  • NYC’s Best Pasta Restaurants
  • The 7 Best Albany Restaurants
  • Where To Find The Best Pizza In New York City 
  • Seven Must-Try Ithaca Restaurants 

Restaurants in Batavia

Fortunes is an Italian steakhouse.

585-367-8863, Batavia, NY 14020

Choose your meal from Fortunes Italian Steak Restaurant at Batavia Downs by rolling the dice. Within the casino, this upscale eatery is a gold mine. Batavia Downs, situated in Genesee County, right off the New York State Thruway, is the country’s oldest illuminated harness racetrack (Interstate 90).

There is bound to be a favorite on their menu, which includes speciality foods such as steak, seafood, and Italian masterpieces.

Begin with the famous Batavia Downs Seafood Chowder or Shrimp Cocktail. When it comes to drinks, choose the Château Batavia Downs Cabernet. A classic with tastes of dark red fruit and black cherry, white round tannins, and a trace of vanilla.

Place a slow-roasted, succulent prime rib coated with herbs and garlic on your platter. It is available in King (14 oz.) or Queen (10 oz.) sizes. This dish comes with garlic dinner rolls and herb butter, as well as your choice of French fries, garlic mashed potatoes, a baked potato, or wild rice pilaf.

Fresh Handmade Lasagna cooked to perfection with homemade sauce, ricotta, mozzarella, braised sausage, and beef. It tastes like cheese.

Let’s dress it up with Seafood Frutti Di Mare. On linguine, shrimp, scallops, clams, and mussels are served with a garlic white wine sauce or a spicy marinara.

Eating at Fortunes is a sure-fire way to win. Extend your stay and take advantage of the entertainment. A stay at the on-site hotel may be combined with fun and cuisine. That will be a rewarding experience.

The Lodge at Batavia Country Club

585-344-8367, Batavia, NY 14020

On a Friday night, The Lodge, situated at the Batavia Country Club Golf Course and Banquet Lodge, is the place to be. Consider it the 19th hole if you’re a golfer. It is not necessary to play golf. Go eat and have fun.

Gather your family and friends for a feast of delectable cuisine. Add an appetizer to your dining list. A popular dish is fried coconut shrimp with pina colada dipping sauce. Artichoke French is a classic dish that is egg-dipped and sautéed in a sherry and lemon butter sauce.

There is pasta, steak, and seafood available, but wait till you try the Fish Fry (soup and salad bar included). What kind of fish do you like? Maybe beer battered, panko breaded, or broiled? Looking for something out of the ordinary? The French Haddock is one alternative. Another option is the Italian Haddock, which is grilled in white wine and butter before being topped with fresh garlic, seasoned breadcrumbs, chopped tomatoes, and mozzarella cheese.

Take advantage of the season. Batavia Country Club can fulfill your requirements whether you want to play a round of golf, have a bite to eat, or need a banquet space for an event or wedding.

The Irish Pub OLacys

Batavia, NY 14020, 585-343-32705 School Street

OLacys Irish Pub is the place to be. You’ll feel right at home in this realistic setting, complete with Irish antiquities adorning the walls. Take your hat off and get a Guinness. Then raise a glass to a nice time and delicious cuisine. Live music may also be present. Get up and start jigging.

Get hungry for these filling dishes. Get the Beef Tips Over Noodles with your choice of soup or salad. The Trinity Reuben is a smashing success. It has corned beef, pastrami, and turkey in it.

There are usually a number of offers available. Fish & Chips or a Shaved Steak Sandwich with peppers, onions, and Swiss cheese are options. All are certain to satisfy.

The natives will greet you with a warm grin. Have a seat and converse for a bit. Listen to tales and laugh along with them. You may not discover a pot of riches, but you will find the food you seek in their cooking pots.

Take some leftovers and this Irish blessing home with you. The road may rise to meet you. May the wind always be on your side. May the sun beam brightly on your face. May the rain be gentle on your crops. And may God keep you in the palm of His hand till we meet again.

The Bourbon and Burger Co.

Batavia, NY 14020 585-219-42429 Jackson Street

Anybody up for a gourmet burger? Pay a visit to Bourbon & Burger Co. Fresh USDA prime beef burgers are cooked to order.

Consider the weekly specialties. Every month, they highlight a different Burger of the Month.

Can you withstand the heat? When you sample The Volcano Burger, which comes with pepper jack cheese, hot sauce, boom boom sauce, jalapenos, and spicy sausage, you may need the fire department on standby.

If you want anything other than a beef burger, try a Bison burger, chicken, turkey, or vegetable patty. There are gluten-free buns available.

The Kentucky Bourbon Company Burger is their trademark burger, topped with bacon, onion rings, lettuce, tomato, and pepper jack cheese and smothered in whiskey sauce.

Individuals with a large appetite can choose the Everything’s Bigger in Texas burger. I’m sure you’ve never heard of this one. This burger includes bacon and fries, however it is served between two grilled cheese sandwiches rather than on a bun. That’s either insane or insanely excellent. You make the call.

Are you torn between breakfast and lunch? Choose the Kansas Breakfast hamburger. This version includes a fried egg, two slices of bacon, and nacho-filled tater tots sprinkled with maple syrup.

The waste plate is found in Western New York. The Trash Plate burger with cheddar cheese, macaroni salad, and chili is unsurprisingly on the menu.

With burgers named after various states and cities, you’ll feel like you’ve journeyed across the country.

God Bless the America, as Lee Greenwood penned in his song.

Across the Texan plains, from sea to shining sea, from Detroit to Houston, and from New York to Los Angeles, there is pride in every American heart.

As you dine here, you can sense the American pride. It will warm your heart while also filling your tummy.

Smoke House on Center Street

Batavia, NY 14020 585-343-747020 Center Street

It has been noted that here is where authentic Southern BBQ and cocktails are prepared correctly. The decoration is eye-catching. While sitting, legs usually go beneath the table, but don’t be shocked if you notice one on a lamp.

This pleasant cocktail is created with Fresca; remember Fresca? The Mr. Clark Wedge is a cocktail made with orange vodka, Fresca (grapefruit soda), a dash of orange juice, and a twist of lime.

Isn’t cornbread essential to every BBQ meal? Did you know there are two kinds of cornbread? Northern cornbread and Southern cornbread. What is the distinction? Northern cornbread is sweeter, lighter, and more cake-like than southern cornbread. Cast-iron skillets are often used to make Southern cornbread. Since wheat and rye did not keep well in the heat and humidity of the South, it became a staple. Whatever you choose, both are delicious with melted butter.

Slow-cooked beef yields a succulent barbeque feast. The encounter is enhanced with a side of cornbread.

If barbecue, brisket, or ribs do not appeal to you, order a Fish Fry. Every Friday, all sweets, including handmade peanut butter pie, are 15% off.

Food trucks from Center Street Smoke House may be seen all throughout town. Their community participation is extensive. Walk along the street or enter and have a seat. You can’t go wrong either way. Enjoy live music and make a song request.

Alex’s Residence

585-344-2999, Park Road, Batavia, New York 14020

Make Alex’s Place yours. They have been serving customers for 25 years and are recognized for their genuine warmth and cozy environment. Individuals go long distances to order their favorites or to try something new. It serves superb meals in a relaxed, informal setting.

The grilled shrimp is a tasty appetizer or a meal on its own. Grilled shrimp skewers are served with pineapple cooked with your choice of sauce.

There are signature burgers available. The Black & Blue burger, which is blackened and seasoned with blue cheese crumbles, is one example.

Go for the ribs if you want the whole experience.

The most well-known meal is their succulent baby back ribs, which fall off the bone and melt in your mouth. Additional favorites include char-grilled favorites and steakhouse specials.

Fresh fish and delicious prime rib au jus are presented with affection, particular care, and substantial amounts.

It is a really award-winning establishment. They took first place in the Independent Health Foundation’s Healthy Choices from Taste of Buffalo competition. Additional prizes were for their Public Choice Best Ribs from Art of Ribs and Roc City Ribfest. Alexs Place was voted Business of the Year by the Genesee County Chamber of Commerce.

BBQ Dinner Kits are now available for purchase. It’s an excellent family-friendly takeaway choice. Whether dining in or taking out, Alexs Place is known for treating every customer like a VIP.

The Main Street Pizza Company

Batavia, NY 14020 585-343-0007206 East Main Street

Tuesday night pasta and wine for two for $28. Wines are available in a number of styles. That is one incentive to visit Main St. Pizza Company.

Their 20 pizzas with sweet sauce set them apart from other pizza joints. Victor Marchese, the proprietor, utilizes his mother’s sauce recipe. They produce grilled (not wood-fired) pizza and deep-dish pizza.

Do you want wings with your pizza? No worries. Raspberry wings are one of 32 kinds of chicken wings available. Yum. The ones grilled over a charcoal fire are a popular option.

At their pasta kitchen, the executive chef makes artistic Italian cuisine. The meatballs are delicious.

This location was originally intended just for locals. It became a popular gathering spot between Rochester and Buffalo, so it was extended to accommodate more people.

It’s a popular stop for folks heading to a Buffalo Bills game or Six Flags Darien Lake Theme Park.

Pizza Today Magazine named Main St. Pizza Company one of the top 100 pizza companies in the United States.

The decor has a 1962 mural depicting ancient Batavia, and the tin ceiling is a distinctive focal point. You’ll be in capable hands here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *