St. Thomas, one of three U.S. Virgin Islands in the Caribbean Sea, is adorned with powdery, sun-drenched beaches, one of the world’s most beautiful ports, and multi-hued azure crystalline seas. This lovely place is endowed with such natural beauty that it is just amazing. It’s no surprise that these greatest St. Thomas restaurants are so popular; they’re actually situated in paradise!
The island’s distinctive Rastafarian laid-back appeal stems from the island’s cultural melting pot. To guests’ pleasure, the island also offers a diverse mix of exquisite cuisines, offered in a broad range of the greatest St. Thomas restaurants.
Surprisingly, in Virgin Island homes, food serves both as a source of nutrition and as a metaphor for life lessons. We were lured to a sign outside the entrance of one of St. Thomas’ eateries that said, When coconut falls from the tree, he can’t fasten back. According to one of the locals, it means that certain things cannot be altered or reversed. Isn’t that correct?
Restaurants may be found around the island, with the majority concentrated in the east and northeast. These are some of our favorite spots to eat, drink, and enjoy the incredible wealth of the islands. Reservations are strongly advised, since guests are returning and numerous post-hurricane eateries have yet to open. But don’t let it stop you from experiencing these seven greatest St. Thomas restaurants.
When in St. Thomas, don’t miss out on the following activities that will let you immerse yourself in the city (get them while they’re hot! ):
- St. Thomas Mangrove Kayak, Hike, & Snorkel 3-Hour Tour
- Saint Thomas: Coral World Ocean Park Ticket
- Sea Trek and Coral World Ocean Park General Admission
Additionally, are you seeking for something to do in between meals? Check out this list of activities to do in St. Thomas that will appeal to the whole family!
7 Top Restaurants in St. Thomas
Mims Seafood Restaurant
Building 15 Watergate Villas, Bolongo Bay (340) 775-2081
We always lunch at Mims no matter how many times we visit St. Thomas, and with good cause. This dinner-only informal beachfront restaurant with a lovely coastal setting has been serving fresh fish and other seafood and island delicacies for over two decades.
One of those specialities is lobster, but we also propose the Snapper Almondine, which is delicately coated with flour before being sautéed and encrusted with toasted almonds and served in a ginger-horseradish sauce with a baked potato and roasted vegetable medley.
I adore pasta, so when I saw their vast pasta menu, I was ecstatic. Our excellent waitress recommended the Shrimp and Crab in a Lobster Cream Sauce. That was, indeed, to die for.
With breathtaking vistas, first-rate service, and delectable cuisine, it’s no surprise that we keep returning to Mims, one of the greatest St. Thomas restaurants.
Gladys Coffee Shop
Royal Dane Mall (340) 774-66045600 Royal Dane Mall
Gladys Caf, located in the center of historic Frenchtown, provides casual Caribbean food for breakfast, lunch, and supper in a beautiful colorful atmosphere. Paintings by local artists decorate the stone walls of the eatery and are for sale. The cuisine is fresh and delicious, and the service is excellent.
We stopped there for lunch and drooled over the Grouper Filet, which was pan-fried Creole-style with local fungus (cornmeal combined with okra), fresh vegetables, and plantains. Jerk-grilled Mahi-Mahi on a toasted sandwich with lettuce, tomato, and chips was another hit. One of the top St. Thomas restaurants offers a diverse cuisine.
Gladys is also recognized for their award-winning handmade spicy sauces, which are so popular that they can be bought online and sent to the mainland. Warning: they are HOT, but they are ALWAYS GOOD. Mango is my particular fave!
Sunset Cove Bar and Restaurant
(340) 693-48007338 Bakkeroe Estate
We were tired and hungry when we arrived in St. Thomas, so we went down to our pool bar-restaurant at Marriott Frenchmans Cove for a late lunch before our villa was ready. The eating experience was so good that we ate there again on our final day before traveling back to the airport.
First and foremost, the scenery is breathtaking. Sunset Cove is an open-air restaurant with all tables overlooking the pool or the ocean. Breakfast, lunch, and supper meals are available, and everything we tried here surpassed our expectations. This isn’t your typical poolside fare.
Mahi Fish Tacos with island slaw served in flour tortillas and topped with a cilantro lime sauce were among our faves (along with some innovative island libations).
Nachos Supreme with beef are a piled-high and loaded tortilla chip dish with cheddar jack cheese, black bean salsa, jalapeos, shredded lettuce, tomatoes, sour cream, and salsa. Despite the fact that it was featured on the appetizer menu, it was huge enough for four of us to share. Finally, the Mango Habanero wings were fantastic.
Don’t ignore the Sunset if you’re searching for beach-front restaurants in St. Thomas; it’s one of the top St. Thomas eateries.
Mafolie
(340) 774-27907091 Mafolie Estate
This well-known St. Thomas institution has been serving travelers and island residents since 1952. Views are stunning from every table, particularly those placed directly on the rail at the boutique Mafolie Hotel, which is perched 866 feet above sea level. It’s the ideal environment for a romantic evening.
Every evening, dinner includes meals from the land and sea, as well as appetizers, soups, and salads. The Mafolie Mango and Avocado Salad with mixed greens, carrots, and a carambola (star fruit) vinaigrette was delicious. For an extra fee, shrimp, chicken, mahi, or tuna may be added. I chose the shrimp, which went well with the salad.
My dining companion chose Spicy Tuna with sweet chile, Japanese seaweed, mashed potato, plantains, and other veggies. The entrees were exquisitely cooked, and the day and evening views are unrivaled.
This is one of the greatest St. Thomas restaurants and should be on your short list for excellent dining in St. Thomas.
Caf Amalia
Palm Passage (340) 714-73735143
This delightful Spanish-inspired restaurant is accessible by a cobblestone path and is open everyday for lunch and supper.
We stopped here for lunch and had a fantastic gastronomic experience. Tapas are the caf’s speciality, and the assortment is outstanding.
We began with Champinones Ajillo, fried garlic mushrooms, and then split the Paella Valenciana, which we had heard was one of the restaurant’s best sellers. This typical Spanish dinner with Saffron rice, chicken, calamari, shrimp, mussels, and clams was delicious. And trust me, there’s a lot to talk about.
Make space for the Banana Blueberry Bread Pudding, which is to die for!
Amalia Caf is the place to go in St. Thomas if you want to explore and taste new, diversified, and distinctive meals. It’s one of the top restaurants in St. Thomas for a reason!
Bluebeards Deck with a View
(340)-643-83661331 Taarneberg Estate
Deck with a View at Bluebeards Castle (previously Room with a View) perches high on a hillside overlooking the dazzling lights of downtown Charlotte Amalie and the cruise ship dock, and was just reopened under a new name.
The open-air supper eating experience also offers spectacular views of Long Bay’s magnificent yacht port. A lovely summer sunset was complemented by gentle evening breezes.
The menu isn’t huge, but it’s well-planned and artistically presented. We asked our server’s advice since this was our first eating experience here and are pleased we did. Soup du Jour, a cream of asparagus with chunks of crab flesh and Gruyere cheese, was a major success.
The Berkshire Porterhouse Grilled Pork Chop with Anson Mills farro risotto with walnuts and parmesan, baby carrots, and a Marsala pork stock reduction was delicious and tender.
Another hit was the Sou Vide New York Strip. The grain-fed black Angus beef from New Zealand was cooked in garlic-herbed duck fat compound butter, divided into four large pieces, and served with crispy crushed fingerling potatoes and asparagus.
This restaurant takes the cake for romantic dining and is undoubtedly one of the top St. Thomas restaurants!
The Duffy’s Love Shack
The phone number is (340) 779-20806500, and the address is Red Hook Plaza.
I realize there are finer eateries on the island, but everyone should go to the legendary parking lot cafe Duffys Love Shack at least once. It’s a kind of rite of passage. If the floating bubbles aren’t enough to entice you, the lime-green shutters and raucous island rock music will.
Duffy’s tropical concoctions are incredibly entertaining, and it’s practically located on the edge of a parking lot in Red Hook, where the boats sail for St. John. In St. Thomas, you won’t find a better pain reliever.
It’s made with black rum, pineapple juice, orange juice, and a hearty amount of cream of coconut, then dusted with nutmeg. It will heal whatever ails you, but be cautious since it has been known to bend a few knees!
Duffys is not a lunch or supper restaurant, but rather a bar that provides delicious food. What’s up? Instead of main courses, we normally order a variety of little snacks to share with our family. Coco Loco Shrimp is a coconut shrimp with a pineapple jalapeno marmalade dip. Jamaican Jerk Nachos are loaded with jerk chicken and delicious.
The Polynesian Pu-Pu Platter, which includes sweet and tangy Fiji wings, Asian beef skewers, sweet plantains, teriyaki riblets, shrimp gyozas, and rum-soaked pineapple, is highly recommended.
In this legendary St. Thomas restaurant, every menu dish is unique and excellent.