Is the 2015 Quarter Too Modern to Be Valuable?

The numismatic market categorizes coins by minting periods, placing 2015 specimens into the modern coinage group.

This year belongs to the America the Beautiful Quarters program launched in 2010.

Determining the 2015 quarter value requires analyzing mintage figures, preservation states, and production defects.

Collector flipping through coin album with 2015 quarter visible

General Mintage Figures for 2015

In 2015, the United States Mint released five distinct designs representing national parks and historic sites.

Production occurred at three primary facilities: Philadelphia (P), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S).

Coins bearing the "S" mark were issued in limited quantities exclusively for collector sets, never entering general circulation.


National Park

Philadelphia Mint (P)

Denver Mint (D)

San Francisco Mint (S - Business Strike)

Homestead (Nebraska)

248.6

214.4

1.05

Kisatchie (Louisiana)

397.2

379.6

1.07

Blue Ridge (North Carolina)

325.8

505.2

1.03

Bombay Hook (Delaware)

275.0

206.4

1.01

Saratoga (New York)

223.4

215.4

1.02


Total output exceeding hundreds of millions for regular circulation excludes any scarcity for ordinary specimens.

Factors Determining High Market Price

The value of a modern coin depends on three primary parameters.

The first parameter involves the grade (condition) determined by the 70-point Sheldon scale.

Coins in MS67 condition and higher appear extremely rarely due to automated packaging and transport processes causing surface micro-damage.

The second factor comprises mint errors occurring during the manufacturing process.

The third factor involves the production material, considering the issuance of special silver versions (90% silver) for collectors.

Exceptional Condition Specimens

Specimens receiving an MS68 grade from independent expert services (a coin value checker app, PCGS, or NGC) show significant price growth relative to face value.

For a 2015-P Homestead quarter in MS68 condition, auction records reach 800–1,200 U.S. dollars.

Price Change Statistics for Graded Coins (MS67-MS68): * Annual price change for MS67 coins: +3-5% depending on the design.

  • Annual price change for rare MS68 specimens: +12-18% resulting from limited registry supply.

  • Price decline for MS65 grade and lower: -10% annually due to the constant influx of new lots from bank rolls.

A detailed study of PCGS registries reveals the number of issued MS68 certificates for 2015 releases being limited to single digits.

San Francisco (S) Collector Issues

Coins with the "S" mint mark are not intended for commercial transactions.

The U.S. Mint sells them in special bags and rolls with a premium markup.

A mintage of 1 million pieces for each design makes them 200–500 times rarer compared to Philadelphia or Denver issues.

The market value of uncirculated "S" specimens from 2015 ranges from 5 to 15 dollars per piece.

Upon reaching an MS68 grade, the price of such a specimen increases to 150–300 dollars.

2015 Mint Errors

Technological failures create unique collectible objects possessing high liquidity.

A well-known variety called "Leaking Bucket" exists for the 2015 Homestead release.

A die chip causing an extra metal flow on the reverse near the bucket image creates this error.

The value of these coins varies from 20 to 150 dollars depending on the defect size.

Other types of confirmed errors include:

  1. Double Die Reverse (DDR): Doubling of design elements most frequently found on the Homestead house windows.

  2. Off-Center Strike: Misalignment of the image relative to the planchet center, valued proportionally to the offset percentage.

  3. Clipped Planchet: A missing portion of the coin disc resulting from the blanking stage.

A Saratoga specimen with a 10-15% off-center strike may cost approximately 100 dollars.

An offset exceeding 50% while retaining the mintage date increases the price to 400–600 dollars.

Silver Versions of 2015 Quarters

Coins were issued as part of Silver Proof Sets.

The coin weighs 6.25 grams, containing 5.625 grams of pure silver.

Investment Indicators for Silver Quarters: * Intrinsic metal value: Dependent on the silver spot price.

  • Numismatic markup: 40–60% above metal price for PR69 grades.

  • Premium for perfect condition (PR70 Deep Cameo): 150–300% above the base set value.

The auction record for a 2015-S quarter set in PR70 DCAM condition stands at approximately 250–400 dollars.

2015 quarter photographed on clean neutral background

Comparative Investment Attractiveness Analysis

Utilizing statistical data allows comparing the 2015 quarters with older issues.


Year of Issue

Design

Average Price (2024/25)

5-Year Growth (%)

1999

Connecticut

$40

+10%

2015

Blue Ridge

$35

+25%

2015

Bombay Hook

$45

+30%

2021

Tuskegee Airmen

$20

+5%


The higher growth rate of the 2015 quarters is explained by demand from collectors seeking to complete the full America the Beautiful series.

The Grading Process and Its Impact on Liquidity

Sending a coin for certification to the coin identifier app or NGC requires costs of 30–60 dollars per unit, including shipping.

For 2015 coins, this procedure becomes economically justified only when anticipating an MS67 grade or higher.

A specimen having visible scratches or traces of circulation loses 99% of its potential collectible value, equaling its face value.

The quantity of 2015-P Saratoga coins in MS68 grade totals fewer than 20 pieces worldwide, confirming their status as extremely rare numismatic objects.

Conclusion

A 2015 quarter is not "too modern" to possess high value under specific conditions.

The bulk of coins in citizens' pockets carries no value exceeding 25 cents.

Investment interest targets exclusively coins in perfect condition (Top Pop), rare die varieties, and confirmed production errors.

Price dynamics for top-tier preservation specimens show steady growth outpacing inflation expectations.

Auction statistics confirm buyers' readiness to pay four-figure sums for flawless 2015 minting examples.

Discovering such coins requires careful study of bank rolls or purchasing already certified assets.

Facts indicate the existence of a narrow but high-value market segment for this specific year of issue.

Further reduction in the supply of "Gem Uncirculated" coins will contribute to maintaining current price trends.