Carmel Indiana’s Finest Pizza | 9 Must-Try Carmel Indiana Pizza Restaurants

Rate this post

Carmel, Indiana is a one-of-a-kind city with a lot to offer. The amazing pizza is something that many people enjoy about the neighborhood.

Carmel is a terrific area to savor Italian food, and inhabitants have plenty of alternatives for superb pizza.

You need to know where to go if you want to get a slice at a neighborhood pizza or order delivery. Nevertheless, with so many possibilities, it may be difficult to choose the ideal restaurant for your supper. Here’s where we come in! We will provide a list of the greatest pizza restaurants in Carmel, Indiana.

Each location has its own own personality and taste, so you should have no trouble finding something you like on our list. So remember to arrive hungry!

We just had to try them all and choose the finest ones in town. Now, have a look at what we discovered and let us know if you agree.

Visiting other places in Indiana? Check out our other tasty guides:

  • The 6 Best Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana
  • 7 Best Must Try Carmel Restaurants
  • 8 Best Fort Wayne Restaurants

Carmel Indiana’s Finest Pizza

The Rosatis Pizza

Carmel, IN 46032 317-983-3638890 E. 116th St.

Rosatis Pizza takes great pride in serving the greatest pizza in Carmel, Indiana.

Their traditional family recipe has been handed down for five generations. Their high-quality ingredients assure that you will have the same experience as their initial consumers over a century ago.

You’ll adore the pizza at Rosatis whether you like Chicago deep-dish or thin crust, or if you can’t decide since they’re all so good.

Rosatis has something for everyone. They provide conventional thin crust, double dough crust, deep-dish pizza, and filled crust pizza. Pick from a variety of toppings to make your own masterpiece.

If you can’t decide, try one of their favorites, such as Rosatis Monster or BBQ Special.

Apart from wonderful pizza, you’ll be astonished to discover a large range of other foods, including salads, spaghetti, wings, dessert, and more.

Whatever you choose, every bite of Rosatis Pizza is of the highest quality.

The Crafters Draft House

Carmel, IN 46033 +131779820562430 E. 146th St.

Crafters Pizzeria, where gourmet meets pizza, is made with the greatest quality ingredients.

Come experience their selection of classic pizzas, unique pies, artisan beers, and bourbons. They build the pizzas with care and bake them to perfection.

You won’t be disappointed whether you choose a substantial, cheesy pie or a little piece created with care and originality.

Taste their Jerry Jones pizza for an unforgettable dining experience. With hickory BBQ sauce, mozzarella, smoked Texas brisket, ham, peppadew peppers, pickled onions, and cilantro, this pizza is a great treat.

Its cuisine provides something for everyone. You’ll have lots of delectable options to make this your new favorite location to dine out, with innovative dishes for everything from appetizers to desserts.

Another compelling incentive to visit Crafters is their excellent customer service.

Crafters has become a neighborhood favorite by providing continuous excellent service, an unique menu, and delicious cuisine!

Mushroom Mellow

Carmel, IN 46032 +131784624002340 E. 116th St.

Do you want to eat anything special? It’s time to meet Mellow Mushroom at Merchants Square on 116th Street. They are a well-known venue for pizza, appetizers, salad, and burgers that Carmel residents like.

You may order anything on the menu at Mellow Mushroom and be certain that you will get the finest experience imaginable. They created their cuisine with the freshest ingredients available, including hand-crafted daily pizza dough.

They provide a wide selection of tasty pizzas and hoagies that will satisfy everyone’s taste buds. Don’t forget to taste one of their signature varieties, such as the Great White or Buffalo Chicken, garnished with a blue cheese or ranch dressing swirl.

Have one of their Magic Mocktails or Magical Teas to go with your amazing pizza. What is my particular favorite? The Cherry Springer is a refreshing concoction of cherry juice and fresh lemon-lime house-made sour mix, enhanced with vanilla and caramel tastes.

Mellow Mushroom is perfect for a quick snack or a nice evening out with friends and family.

Carmel’s Lou Malnati’s

Carmel, IN 46032 +1317975198011435 Spring Mill Rd. Suite 170

Lou Malnatis Pizzeria is a family-owned and run restaurant franchise that provides some of Carmel, Indiana’s greatest pizza. Not only are Lou Malnatis restaurants located across Indiana, but they have also extended to Arizona, Wisconsin, and Illinois.

Lou Malnati’s history is as colorful as their pizza. Malnatis success originates from its drive to quality. Every Lou Malnati pizza is made by hand using only the greatest and freshest ingredients.

Every year, the Malnati team handpicks California vine-ripened tomatoes for the perfect sweet and tangy taste of their sauces. Moreover, their special sausage mix is carefully seasoned to generate the best pizzas.

Not to mention their fresh mozzarella cheese, which is supplied by the same local dairy that has supplied Lou Malnati’s for over 40 years.

They are well-known for their exceptional Chicago-style pizzas and their secret family recipe for making the unbelievably tasty dough. One of Carmel, Indiana’s best pizzas.

While ordering or going by, be sure to taste The Lou, their Deep Dish. I’m certain you’ll appreciate every mouthful!

Pizza Blaze

Carmel, IN 46032 +1317343919312697 N. Pennsylvania St.

Blaze Pizza is an excellent choice for a fast lunch or supper with friends.

By enabling you to customise your order, Blaze Pizza can put a new twist on your favorite slice. You may build your own ideal pizza from their selection of freshly prepared dough, sauces, cheeses, and mouthwatering toppings.

You may choose from a variety of crusts, such as a gluten-free cauliflower crust or a keto crust. Then, choose your sauce; if you want to experiment, try their fiery red sauce or garlic pesto sauce.

With a choice of cheeses to select from, including vegan cheese, a pizza from Blaze will satisfy the whole crew. Top it with some meats and vegetables, then top it with a delectable touch like their balsamic glaze, and you’ll have the ultimate pizza slice!

Blaze Pizza is the place to go if you want pizza in Carmel Indiana that is not only delicious but also quick.

Pizza by Bazbeaux

Carmel, IN 46032 +13178484488111 W. Main St.

When it comes to exceptional cuisine and courteous service, Bazbeaux is the only name you need to know! They provide an upmarket eating experience in a warm and friendly rustic setting.

Bazbeaux Pizza in Carmel, Indiana, has a number of speciality pizzas on their menu, including The Luke and Tchoupitoulas, so you’re sure to find something to satisfy your taste buds.

The Luke speciality pizza has Buffalo chicken and blue cheese, red onion, and fresh celery for a taste explosion like no other!

Their menu also includes cobb salad, crab salad, fresh mozzarella platters, and a variety of sandwiches.

If you like trying new things, you’ll enjoy Bazbeaux Pizza in Carmel’s Arts District!


Carmel, IN 46033 +1317844255013190 Hazel Dell Pkwy Ste. 180

Pizzology is the genuine thing, a local pizza shop in Carmel that specializes in wood-fired pizzas made with high-quality ingredients.

They provide a variety of unusual pizzas that are guaranteed to please any palette. The Pepperoni Piquante, topped with pepperoni, peppadew peppers, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan, and fresh oregano, is at the top of my list.

Not to mention their renowned Bee Keeper pizza, which is created with soppressata, honey, jalapenos, and fresh mozzarella. It’s a true masterpiece!

Not only does Pizzology offer a unique menu with inventive pizzas, but they also have a large selection of appetizers, pasta, and delectable desserts.

This distinctive pizza provides something for everyone, from tried-and-true classics to exciting new tastes.

Greeks Pizza Restaurant

Carmel, IN 46032 +13178481969120 E. Main St.

The pizza and breadsticks at Greeks are among the finest in town! They are quick and pleasant, and you can always expect outstanding service from them.

They cook all of their dishes from scratch and utilize only the finest ingredients. The pizza sauce is fantastic, and the dough is hand-tossed and cooked to perfection in a brick oven, resulting in a highly crispy exterior and soft within.

My favorite is the vegetable pizza, but they also offer gourmet meat pizzas if you’re feeling more experimental.

Get the Greeks Special Pizza, which comes with their signature Italian sauce, a cheese mix, Italian sausage, Spanish onions, baked ham, green bell peppers, sliced domestic mushrooms, and additional sliced pepperoni. It’s a great taste explosion!

This restaurant is a must-try because of its fresh ingredients, delectable sauce, and outstanding crust! So come on down and enjoy some of the greatest pizza in Carmel, Indiana.

Pies and Pints

Carmel, IN 46032 +1317688747714550 Clay Terrace Blvd. Suite 100

When you want something new but equally delicious, this is the spot to go in Carmel, Indiana!

Pies & Pints is a family-owned and run brewery, pizza, and bar that serves a diverse selection of beer and cuisine. It’s a terrific spot to have some nice meals and a cold drink.

They offer incredibly innovative pizza options that are unlike anything you’ll find at other Carmel eateries. This pizza business offers gourmet toppings and innovative sauce combinations on its pizzas. Salads, sandwiches, and snacks are also available.

There are lots of alternatives, particularly for those looking to try something new, such as my personal favorite, the Chicken Gouda, which is topped with applewood smoked bacon, red onions, chipotle crème, and scallions. Very delicious!

Its unique tastes, excellent service, and convenient location make this a unique spot to gather friends for a drink and some wonderful cuisine.

If you go to this pizza, don’t forget to wash it all down with a local artisan beer.

An Overview of the Finest Pizza in Carmel, Indiana

When you think of Italian cuisine in Indiana, you think of excellent pizza and pasta. Carmel has long been renowned as a hidden treasure for many sorts of Italian food. They have some of the top pizza joints in Indiana.

This list offers something for everyone, from pizzerias offering traditional Italian cuisine to unique mixes of classic and contemporary toppings. Furthermore, with so many alternatives available, you’ll have no issue choosing the perfect spot to satisfy your pizza desire.

Check out our top picks and let us know what you think.

Which of these Carmel Indiana pizza shops will you try first? Please share your thoughts in the comments box below!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *