Italian cuisine is among the greatest in the world, and we Americans like it! Discovering new food to try is often a challenge while traveling, but when it comes to Italian restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, you can be certain that you’ll be receiving the finest.
Italian cuisine is popular in the neighborhood! Several of the top restaurants in town dish up delectable platters of pasta, pizza, and other Italian specialties.
What distinguishes these restaurants? It’s their genuineness and usage of fresh local foods. They offer a comprehensive menu and wine selection, and they take pleasure in delivering classic Italian meals with a modern touch.
I’ve got you covered whether you’re traveling or simply searching for something new to try. This area is brimming with excellent Italian restaurants, and in my quest for the best of the best, I tried a couple and chose some of my favorites!
If you’re searching for a new place to dine, go no further than one of these top-rated restaurants!
Visiting other places in Indiana? Check out our other tasty guides:
- The 6 Best Mexican Restaurants In Carmel Indiana
- 7 Best Must Try Carmel Restaurants
- 8 Best Fort Wayne Restaurants
Carmel Indiana’s Top 5 Italian Restaurants
Carmel, IN 46032 +13175644126211 W. Main St. Suite 102
Savor is a one-of-a-kind restaurant that combines traditional Italian and current Mediterranean food. Their menu has a broad selection of freshly prepared meals produced with the freshest local ingredients, ranging from handmade pasta to luscious desserts and a wine list to match any meal.
This restaurant serves Italian cuisine in a unique approach that is guaranteed to gratify your taste buds. Every dish is prepared over a wood fire in an open kitchen, and their chefs work tirelessly to ensure that every meal is fresh, tasty, and cooked to perfection.
Begin your lunch with their delectable Tortellini Michelangelo, a fresh seafood dish, or Crispy Rock Shrimp, a dish meant to be shared!
Savor Restaurant is committed to highlighting the finest of what Italy has to offer. Savor’s great service, delectable cuisine, and one-of-a-kind eating setting await you today.
Carmel, IN 46032 (317) 689-633011505 N. Illinois St.
You’ll know you’re in for a great experience the moment you walk inside Osteria by Fabio Viviani. Situated near to the Market District and inspired by chef Fabio Viviani’s Italian ancestry, this is a one-of-a-kind bistro among Carmel Indiana’s Italian restaurants that delivers a dining experience unlike any other!
The food at Osteria is inspired by the simplicity and variety of Italian life. Their chefs create seasonally inspired meals with fresh ingredients and local products, including enhanced versions on traditional comfort foods and local craft brews and cocktails.
Eat in a modern setting with a cuisine that includes handmade pasta, Neapolitan-style pizza, salads, and traditional Italian meat dishes!
Not sure where to begin? Try the Calabrian Chili Orecchiette, a clam meal with white wine, olive oil, garlic, cherry tomatoes, and parsley and basil garnish. A very delectable refresher!
All of their tasty Italian classics and inventive creations are guaranteed to delight.
Pizza by Bazbeaux (Carmel)
Carmel, IN 46032 +13178484488111 W. Main St.
Bazbeaux is the only name you need to know if you’re searching for one of the greatest Italian restaurants in Carmel Indiana with amazing cuisine and pleasant service.
This Italian restaurant in Carmel’s Art District provides an exquisite dining experience in a warm and friendly rustic setting. Prepare your taste buds for a feast.
Whether you prefer classic toppings or more creative taste combinations, their broad menu will not disappoint. Moreover, when traditional favorites like The Luke and Tchoupitoulas are considered, their homemade pizzas are guaranteed to make your mouth wet.
The Luke, with Buffalo chicken and blue cheese, red onion, and fresh celery, is a taste explosion you’ve never had before.
You’ll also like their delectable beginning salads including cobb salad, crab salad, and fresh mozzarella platters.
Its extensive menu will satisfy your hunger while also delighting your taste senses.
Italian Artisan Food at Convivio
Carmel, IN 46032 317-564-467011529 Spring Mill Rd. Suite #300
Convivio is one of Carmel Indiana’s greatest Italian restaurants, serving homemade pasta, pizzas, entrees, and regional specialities. Their menus vary seasonally, and they distinguish themselves by utilizing all-natural fruits, meats, and cheese.
All of their meals, including their fresh pasta, are created with genuine and careful care to showcase traditional Italian culinary traditions.
Convivio creates their wonderful pasta using the most recent and cutting-edge pasta equipment imported straight from Italy. The most fascinating aspect of this restaurant, though, is its open kitchen, which enables you to see the preparation process.
As you wait for your order, you may have a glass of wine at this restaurant. The chefs are working hard to provide the most flavorful and distinctive foods for you.
Are you a true gourmand? I’ve collected a selection of the greatest gourmet presents for you and your loved ones. Subscriptions for cheese, meat, and sweets, as well as some classic must-have gourmet devices.
Are you feeling daring? Taste their Pappardelle al Cinghiale, a pasta dish mixed with braised wild boar, carrots, celery, and rosemary. It’s unlike anything you’ve ever seen!
They refer to their customers as guests because they treat them in the same manner in which they would treat visitors in their own home. So, come spend the evening at Convivio.
Carmel, IN 46032 +1 317-848-4600620 S. Rangeline Rd.
You thought finding real Italian cuisine in Carmel was impossible? Well, the hunt is finished.
Ristorante Roma is a family-owned Italian restaurant that specializes in Italian cuisine with a contemporary twist, bringing a small piece of Italy to Carmel for everyone to enjoy. They take pride in the Italian traditions of warmth, friendliness, and excellent service.
Restaurant Roma makes handcrafted pasta and gnocchi on a daily basis, utilizing only traditional methods and recipes. Enjoy one of their traditional dishes, such as La Bolognese or Asorrentina.
Or try my favorite, Aboscaiola, prepared in a superbly seasoned cream sauce with exquisite Chardonnay wine-marinated sausage and champignon mushroom. Freshly ground black pepper and Parmigiano cheese are added as finishing touches!
We promise that no matter what you purchase, you will return for more. They are dedicated to providing a personalized dining experience that is distinctively yours each and every time you come.
The Top 5 Must-Try Italian Restaurants in Carmel, Indiana
Trying new food is one of the nicest parts about traveling. Yet when you live in an area with so much amazing Italian cuisine, it might be difficult to choose just one. At these top-rated Italian restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, you can dig into something tasty and real. Both tourists and locals agree that these restaurants deliver the greatest Italian cuisine in town!
Which of these Italian restaurants in Carmel will you try first? Please share your thoughts in the comments box below!